How Options Market Makers Distort 13F Holdings Data
Susquehanna reports $868 billion in 13F value, but it is an options market maker, not a traditional asset manager. Here is why reported 13F values for firms like SIG, Citadel, and Jane Street do not mean what most investors think.
When retail investors scan 13F filings for the largest institutional holders, names like Susquehanna International Group routinely appear near the top with reported values exceeding $800 billion. That figure places SIG alongside Vanguard and BlackRock in raw dollar terms. But the comparison is misleading, because Susquehanna is an options market maker, not a traditional asset manager.
TL;DR
- Options market makers like Susquehanna, Citadel Advisors, and Jane Street file 13F-HR reports that include the notional value of equity options positions alongside their stock and ETF hedges.
- The resulting "reported 13F value" vastly overstates their actual economic exposure to the market.
- SPY, QQQ, IWM, and other broad ETFs dominate their top holdings because these are hedging instruments, not directional bets.
- Investors should treat these filings as a map of market-making activity, not a portfolio to copy.
What Is an Options Market Maker?
An options market maker provides liquidity by continuously quoting bid and ask prices on options contracts. When a retail investor buys a call option on Tesla through their brokerage, an options market maker is often on the other side of that trade. To manage the risk from holding thousands of simultaneous options positions, the firm delta-hedges by buying or selling the underlying stock or ETF.
This hedging activity is what shows up in the 13F filing. The firm does not "want" to own 224 million shares of NVIDIA or $77 billion of SPY. These positions exist to offset options risk.
Why Reported 13F Value Is Not AUM
For a traditional asset manager like Fidelity (FMR) or Capital World Investors, the 13F value closely approximates the assets they manage on behalf of clients. When Fidelity reports $1.96 trillion, that represents real client money invested in stocks.
For an options market maker, the 13F value is a byproduct of hedging. Consider Susquehanna's Q4 2025 filing:
| Metric | Susquehanna (SIG) | FMR (Fidelity) |
|---|---|---|
| Reported 13F value | $868 billion | $1.96 trillion |
| Business model | Options market making | Asset management |
| Top holding | SPY (9.6%) | NVDA (10.3%) |
| Positions | 13,927 | 5,139 |
| Represents | Hedging book | Client portfolios |
The $868 billion figure for Susquehanna includes the value of shares held as delta hedges against options books. The actual capital at risk is a fraction of this number.
How to Spot an Options-Heavy Filer
Several signals help identify when a 13F is dominated by options market-making activity:
- ETF concentration in top holdings: When SPY, QQQ, IWM, and GLD dominate the top positions, the filer is likely hedging broad market exposure rather than making stock picks.
- Unusually high position count with broad diversification: Market makers hold positions across thousands of names because they provide liquidity across the entire listed options market.
- Rapid AUM swings between quarters: A 20-30% quarterly change in reported value often reflects shifts in options inventory and hedging needs, not capital inflows or outflows.
- Put and call columns populated: 13F filings include columns for put and call options. When these are heavily populated, the underlying share positions are hedges.
The Biggest Options Market Makers Filing 13Fs
| Firm | Q4 2025 Reported 13F Value | Primary Business |
|---|---|---|
| Susquehanna International Group | $868 billion | Options market making, quantitative trading |
| Citadel Advisors | $666 billion | Multi-strategy hedge fund + market making |
| Jane Street Group | $662 billion | Quantitative trading, ETF market making |
Combined, these three firms report over $2 trillion in 13F value. None of that represents traditional assets under management in the way investors typically understand the term.
What Investors Should Do With This Information
When you see an options market maker appear as a top holder of a stock you own, it does not signal institutional conviction in that company. Instead:
- Filter by filer type: Focus on traditional asset managers, mutual funds, and pension funds when analyzing institutional ownership signals.
- Check the WhaleScore: On 13F Insight, WhaleScore helps identify filers whose holdings carry genuine signal value versus those dominated by trading activity.
- Look at position changes, not absolute size: Even for market makers, meaningful quarter-over-quarter changes in specific positions can signal shifting options flow and market sentiment.
- Use "reported 13F value" language: When discussing these firms, always say "reported 13F value" rather than "AUM" or "assets under management" to avoid implying traditional investment management.
FAQ
Related Research
Explore all researchVictory Capital kept mega-cap tech on top in Q4 2025, but the sharper signal was in the secondary moves: large increases in Netflix, Constellation Energy, TSMC and new positions like IQVIA. The next filing will show whether that diversification continues.
Apr 17, 2026
Fisher’s Q4 2025 filing was still packed with mega-cap tech, but the bigger tell was a giant Treasury and investment-grade corporate bond sleeve built through IEF and VCIT. The next filing will show whether that duration bet was tactical or structural.
Apr 17, 2026
Dodge & Cox’s Q4 2025 filing barely moved on headline AUM, but the underlying changes were more interesting: fresh positions in Brookfield, TransUnion and PDD inside a still-diversified value book. The next filing will show whether those adds were conviction moves or just incremental reshuffling.
Apr 17, 2026
AllianceBernstein kept Nvidia, Microsoft and Amazon on top in Q4 2025, but new exposure to Intuitive Surgical and aggressive increases in Netflix and ServiceNow made the next filing more interesting than another mega-cap recap. Here is what to watch.
Apr 17, 2026
Principal’s Q4 2025 filing looked slightly weaker on headline AUM, but the internal rotation was more revealing: Brookfield became a top-ten position, Netflix surged, and the fund cut back in parts of real estate. The next filing will show whether that shift keeps going.
Apr 17, 2026